Skip to Content

9 Worst Pieces of Gardening Advice that Keep Getting Passed On

“Now the easiest way to tell if a tomato is ripe is to see if it looks purple under a full moon.”

Gardening is filled with so much lore and myth it can be hard to weed out (Ha, gotcha!) the truth from the trash.

Gardening advice has been passed from one gardener to another since we figured out how to grow things in the dirt. And if your Uncle Jim, who is the family green thumb, says it works, it must be good advice, right?

The truth is there’s a lot of bad advice out there.

Nearly all gardening advice is anecdotal, having been passed from generation to generation. And while there’s nothing inherently wrong with that, it doesn’t mean the suggestions have any real merit. Sometimes it’s meaningless fluff that adds up to more work for you without any noticeable benefit to your plants.

But there is some gardening advice that does more harm than good.

One area where we see a lot of bad advice, rather than help, is when commercial agricultural practices cross over into the home gardener’s territory. Many of these practices are necessary when growing single crops on huge masses of land year after year. But when applied to the smaller scale of the garden in your backyard, they simply don’t work or are completely unnecessary.

Let’s take a look at some of the worst gardening advice that continues to get passed from gardener to gardener, year after year.

Maybe we can put a stop to it and save ourselves some time and frustration.

1. “You Need to Rotate Your Crops Every Year.”

Soybeans and corn grown in wide swathes on this large commercial farm.
Soybeans this year, then corn the next, just keep moving to the left.

Let’s just jump right in with one that’s going to make a few people’s blood boil.

Crop rotation is one of those practices that came to use from commercial agriculture. And it makes sense on a large scale.

If you’re growing the same crop on the same piece of land (whose nutrient value has already been depleted by commercial farming) every year, you’re going to deplete the soil of certain nutrients. This kind of farming is incredibly hard on the soil, so crop rotation is an absolute must in this scenario.

But for home gardeners, most of us fertilize our plants throughout the growing season and add compost to our garden every year.

Gardening on this scale isn’t going to suck all of the nutrients out of your soil in the same way commercial farming does.

Now, that isn’t to say that you should never practice crop rotation as a home gardener. Rotating crops when one of your vegetables was hit by disease or pests can help prevent the same issue from popping up again next year.

But if rotating the crops in your garden year after year is beginning to feel like figuring out the seating for a large wedding reception, then, by all means, you can put this practice to bed.

2. “If You Use Compost, You Won’t Need to Fertilize Your Plants.”

A man sprinkles compost into his garden from a bucket.
“It’s all I need, it’s black gold!”

You can’t read a gardening website without hearing about the many virtues of compost. And let’s be honest, for a pile of rotting stuff, compost does amazing things for your plants.

However, it doesn’t do everything.

Compost doesn’t have many of the necessary nutrients your plants need during the growing season. At least not yet. Compost is great for water retention and slowly adding nutrients back to the soil, all while improving the soil structure.

Your plants will need specific nutrients at different times during the growing season. And that’s where fertilizers come in.

Compost and fertilizer work together. Add both to your garden for happy, healthy plants.

3. “Using Soaker Hose is the Easiest Way to Water Your Garden.”

Oh, soaker hose, in theory, is pretty great. It saves you time, and everything gets watered at once.

Raised beds with soaker hose laid out on the soil.
“Soaker hose is going to make things so much easier this year!”

You lay down the hose throughout your entire garden or raised beds at the beginning of the season. Then, whenever your plants need to be watered, you just turn the tap on for a few minutes. Ta-dah – a perfectly watered garden! Done. Boom. Relax.

Or not.

What if your lettuce looks parched and needs a drink, but your tomatoes will burst if they get any more water?

Hmm, a soaker hose doesn’t seem all that great then.

Watering your entire garden indiscriminately is a great way to end up with diseased and water-logged plants. Remember, every plant you’re growing has specific needs, and a one-size-fits-all watering system is going to make some plants happy while harming others.

Skip the soaker hose and pay attention to your plants’ individual needs. Probably the best thing you can do to keep your plants moist is mulch.

4. “If You Want the Best Garden, You Should Build Raised Beds.”

Come on; everyone’s doing it. You want to be one of the cool gardeners, right? Well, as great as raised beds are (and they are pretty great) for many people, there are still some good reasons not to garden with them.

Well kept raised beds filled with healthy vegetables.
Now this is how everyone should garden.

Before you head to the hardware store to pick up building supplies for new raised beds, consider these six reasons why raised beds may not be the best gardening method for you.

5. “Tilling Your Ground Is Important to the Health of Your Soil.”

A red rototiller sits next to a stretch of newly tilled lawn.
Has tilling entered the realm of, “But that’s the way we’ve always done it!”

Hoo-boy, this one has been handed down for millennia. Some of humankind’s earliest tools were tools to work the earth. Cutting into the soil adds air, it helps cut up and kill weeds, and it mixes in any soil amendments we might be adding.

Okay, but what about raised beds? They seem to grow just fine each year without running a rototiller through them. Or how about, I don’t know, nature. Plants seem to grow just fine out there in the wide world without us tilling up the forest and every meadow.


It’s only recently that we’ve begun to see the damage we do to the soil when we till. This is one area where we can actually study what’s going on down there, just beneath the sod. And it turns out quite a bit. The microbial life that inhabits the soil is mindboggling.

Unfortunately, we’re finding that tilling the earth does more harm than good.

Let’s take a look at the most common reasons for tilling your garden.

Aerating the soil

Yup, this one is important, but by tilling your garden, you’re also killing off all the beneficial microbes by exposing them to air. Keeping your soil aerated (and less compacted) is easy to accomplish without turning over the soil by using dedicated paths in your garden.

Killing weeds

In theory, this is true. By tilling, you’re killing existing weeds by uprooting them. You’re also bringing dormant weed seeds to the surface who will thank you for waking them so they can enjoy your garden too.

Mixing in soil amendments  

It’s important to make sure your plants have everything they need, and sometimes that means adding compost, or a little lime or a fertilizer like bone meal.

However, it’s important to keep in mind that the roots plants use to take up these nutrients, feeder roots, are relatively shallow growing. By tilling in your amendments, you’re making it harder for your plants to access them.

The best way to make sure your garden benefits from soil amendments is by putting it on top of the dirt where it will soak down into the soil.

I know this one is tough to hear, I too enjoy starting up the ol’ Troy-Bilt and tilling under all the things that went wrong last year. But this year, we’re going no-dig. If you’re interested in skipping the digging this year, check out a few more reasons why it’s the way to go. You can also learn some common no-dig gardening mistakes to avoid.

6. “Your Lawn is Bad for the Planet; You Should Get Rid of It.”

Shot of a green lawn with violets, clover, and dandelions growing in it.
Now this is my kind of lawn – more clover than grass, and pretty little flowers everywhere.

We need lawns.

Let’s face it; no one wants to play soccer in a field full of flowers. Good luck finding the ball if it gets kicked out of bounds. Where is out of bounds anyway? Over by the daisies. Wait, I thought it was by that patch of chicory over there.

And having a few friends over for a barbecue in an overgrown backyard full of native grasses and flowers in August sounds more like a fire hazard than a party.

The idea of letting our lawns return to nature keeps popping up everywhere these days. And when it comes to going green, there seems to be this all-or-nothing attitude in the advice doled out.

But let’s take a moment to acknowledge how great lawns are.

I’m not talking about the pristine chemically maintained, day-glow green lawns, where nary a dandelion dare tread. These are the lawns that are sprinkler-fed every morning by an in-ground sprinkler system and have little flags marking where CHEM-GREEN CO. just sprayed.

Yes, these lawns are bad for the environment, and they really should go.

I’m talking about lawns where native broad-leaf plants are allowed to mix and mingle with the grass. White clover, dandelion, and violets all add a lovely pop of color to your backyard. I’m talking about that place where you play croquet with your family, and your oldest accuses your youngest of moving their ball while you weren’t looking.

And having a cleared space can be important if you live on the edge of the woods or a field. That area that gets mowed and kept up regularly keeps encroaching invasive species in the woods. It also helps to keep ticks at bay.

Instead of getting rid of your lawn entirely, consider a wild-ish lawn.

Stop treating your lawn with chemicals. Enjoy the variety of short grass-like plants instead of a single patch of one type of grass. You’ll be amazed at how many of these produce delicate and beautiful flowers. Mow your lawn less frequently, and when you do, leave it a shaggy 4″.

Remember, you don’t have to give your entire lawn back to nature. If you want to be a part of the movement to rewild, pick an area, even a small corner of your yard, and let that go. You may find you enjoy having less lawn to care for, and then you can decide to rewild a bit more. Or not.

7. “Sprinkle Coffee Grounds Around Your Roses/Hydrangea/Camellias.”

A woman holds a bin of dried coffee grounds. She has a handful ready to sprinkle on her garden.
Why should coffee drinkers have all the fun. If we’re throwing leftover dregs to our plants, let the tea drinkers in on it too.

I keep seeing this one pop up everywhere. I think it has more to do with coffee drinkers wanting to feel that our habit has some useful purpose more than anything else.

You hear that coffee will make your hydrangea turn blue because it will raise your soil’s acidity. I hate to break it to you, but nearly all of the acid in coffee is in your coffee cup. If you want to acidify your soil, your best bet is pelletized sulfur.

And as for sprinkling coffee grounds around other flowering plants, there’s nothing special about coffee here. You’re sprinkling organic matter around a plant. It will slowly break down and release its nutrients back into the soil. You could put almost any kitchen scraps under your roses and get the same effect.

8. “You Can Grow Anything in Containers!”

Containers of onions and basil are growing on a patio in the sun.
Twice the work for half the harvest. Is it worth it? Maybe.

Container gardening has really taken off over the last decade. As someone who recently moved into a second-story apartment without a scrap of lawn (wild or otherwise) to call my own, I’m a huge fan of container gardening.

But there seems to be this idea that you can take any plant and plop it in a big enough pot, and it will reward you with the same amount of produce that you would get from a well-tended garden.

Some plants are just happier when planted directly in the ground.

Here’s a list of vegetables that do well in containers.

Add to that the fact that container gardening takes a lot of work and extra time, and your best option might not be that cute planter on your back patio. Plants grown in containers dry out so much faster than in a traditional garden. In high summer, I have plenty of plants that need to be watered twice a day to keep them healthy and producing.

Because of their size and how often they need to be watered, container crops also require fertilizer much more frequently.

If you have the option and are looking to maximize your yields, my advice is to grow in the ground or raised beds. If like me, growing in the ground isn’t an option, or you want to grow something for fun, or it doesn’t matter if you get a lot of produce from it, by all means, grow it in a container.

9. “Gardening is Easy; Anyone Can Do It.”

Oh, this one. This one makes me crazy.

A near perfect vegetable garden with neat rows, no weeds and large, healthy vegetable plants everywhere.
Some gardeners make it look so easy. Don’t be fooled.

Only one of these statements is true – yes, anyone can garden. No, gardening is not easy.

In our enthusiasm to share our hobby, I wish more of us were honest about how much work gardening is. I wonder how many new gardeners each year are still at it by August, or how many of them have given up out of sheer frustration.

As any experienced gardener should tell you, it takes a lot of planning, hard work, and time to pull off a garden each year. Even with all our effort, if the weather doesn’t cooperate or you deal with pests, it’s all for naught.

I remember a growing season about three years ago where we had torrential downpours all summer. I think we managed to get a few salad bowls of lettuce and three zucchinis before our garden drowned. (This was also the year our pond overflowed, and we were scooping goldfish up out of the grass with mason jars and pitching them back into the pond.)

I'm holding a mason jar with dirty water and a goldfish in it. In the background my yard is flooded.
Talk about overwatering.

Gardening is a constant battle of wits and grit against the elements. And yet, when you pick that first, fresh pea or bite into a ruby red strawberry, all of the hard work is worth it. There is a sense of pride and dignity in working with your hands and bringing forth food up out of the dirt.  

That’s why we keep at it because it’s rewarding. And that’s what we should be telling new gardeners –

“Gardening is hard but so incredibly rewarding; anyone can do it.”

I hope this list will make gardening a bit easier for you by clearing away some unhelpful gardening advice. As we all know, it’s hard enough to get right as it is. But so rewarding.

Get the famous Rural Sprout newsletter delivered to your inbox.

Including Sunday ramblings from our editor, Tracey, as well as “What’s Up Wednesday” our roundup of what’s in season and new article updates and alerts.

We respect your email privacy

Tracey Besemer

Hey there, my name is Tracey. I’m the editor-in-chief here at Rural Sprout.

Many of our readers already know me from our popular Sunday newsletters. (You are signed up for our newsletters, right?) Each Sunday, I send a friendly missive from my neck of the woods in Pennsylvania. It’s a bit like sitting on the front porch with a friend, discussing our gardens over a cup of tea.

Originally from upstate NY, I’m now an honorary Pennsylvanian, having lived here for the past 18 years.

I grew up spending weekends on my dad’s off-the-grid homestead, where I spent much of my childhood roaming the woods and getting my hands dirty.

I learned how to do things most little kids haven’t done in over a century.

Whether it was pressing apples in the fall for homemade cider, trudging through the early spring snows of upstate NY to tap trees for maple syrup, or canning everything that grew in the garden in the summer - there were always new adventures with each season.

As an adult, I continue to draw on the skills I learned as a kid. I love my Wi-Fi and knowing pizza is only a phone call away. And I’m okay with never revisiting the adventure that is using an outhouse in the middle of January.

These days, I tend to be almost a homesteader.

I take an eclectic approach to homesteading, utilizing modern convenience where I want and choosing the rustic ways of my childhood as they suit me.

I’m a firm believer in self-sufficiency, no matter where you live, and the power and pride that comes from doing something for yourself.

I’ve always had a garden, even when the only space available was the roof of my apartment building. I’ve been knitting since age seven, and I spin and dye my own wool as well. If you can ferment it, it’s probably in my pantry or on my kitchen counter. And I can’t go more than a few days without a trip into the woods looking for mushrooms, edible plants, or the sound of the wind in the trees.

You can follow my personal (crazy) homesteading adventures on Almost a Homesteader and Instagram as @aahomesteader.

Peace, love, and dirt under your nails,